Date: Tue Mar 10 08:45:46 2009 Back to Contents ------------------------------------------------------------------------

Author: Zani, Gerald

Subject: Re: stereo speakers

Post:

This is a multi-part message in MIME format.

------_=_NextPart_001_01C9A17B.FDC29576
Content-Type: text/plain;
charset="iso-8859-1"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

Anthony,

Audio amplifiers and audio speakers are not a good example of Ohm's Law.

"If one replaces the speaker with one that has a lower
resistance, does this mean that the current (and power) will increase =
for
a given voltage?"

Yes, But...

"Or is it that for a given power (volume), the current
will increase while the voltage will decrease (since R is now less)? "

Yes. =20

The current will increase if you use a lower IMPEDANCE (not resistance!) =
speaker but not in a simple Ohm's Law fashion. =20
The output voltage of the source amplifier will get pulled down by the =
The audio waveform will get distorted and despite drawing more power it =
will be not as loud or as pure sounding.

A speaker is not a good introductory example of Ohm's law because it is =
not a purely resistive load. The phase between the voltage and the =
current does not allow the use of the term resistance.

The output of an audio amplifier is not a good example of an ideal =
voltage source. Audio bridging is different than the more typical =
impedance matching of a power supply to a load.

In audio terms this is called bridging the source to the load. With =
audio connections one cares about bridging the source with the load in =
such a way that the source does not lose it voltage. The impedance of =
an audio source is often much lower than the impedance of the audio load =
and contrary to common thought the impedances are not matched as they =
would be with a power supply.

Some Articles:

Impedance matching with speakers =20
D. Rae Carpenter, Jr.=20
Phys. Teach. 30 516 (1992)=20

How things work=97Never throw a 2-inch speaker away: It has many uses =20
H. Richard Crane Editor=20
Phys. Teach. 30 375 (1992)

- J

-----Original Message-----
From: tap-l-owner@lists.ncsu.edu on behalf of Anthony Lapinski
Sent: Mon 3/9/2009 8:17 PM
To: tap-l@lists.ncsu.edu; phys-l@carnot.physics.buffalo.edu
Subject: [tap-l] stereo speakers
=20
I was discussing Ohm's law today, and a few students were asking about
stereo speakers and their resistance. Textbooks do few problems =
involving
speakers. From my understanding, a typical speaker is 8 ohms. This will
get a certain amount of current and voltage, providing a power (P =3D =
IV) to
the speakers. If one replaces the speaker with one that has a lower
resistance, does this mean that the current (and power) will increase =
for
a given voltage? Or is it that for a given power (volume), the current
will increase while the voltage will decrease (since R is now less)? And
the implication is that when the volume is turned up (P increases), an
amplifier must have a better power rating to supply the sound if the
speaker resistance is lower.

Is this correct? Can anyone provide some "basic" physics information =
speakers, amplifiers, and Ohm's law?

------_=_NextPart_001_01C9A17B.FDC29576
Content-Type: application/ms-tnef;
name="winmail.dat"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
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