Date: Fri, 8 Nov 2002 09:37:22 -0500
Author: "Jason St. John"
Subject: Re: Hot Chocolate Effect - On Video Encyclopedia of Physics Demos?
Wolf's variation makes me think of a chemistry explanation: Most gases
dissolve much better in cool water than in hot water. Perhaps the hot tap
water, freshly aerated and sitting in the open air, loses its gaseous
content to the air (pitch goes down) before it begins the coffee trick.
Jason St. John 617.353.2634 email@example.com
Boston University Physics Lecture Demonstrations
On 2002-11-07.17:18 firstname.lastname@example.org sent:
> This demo is 3D30.77. Maybe the references will provide a
>lead. A web search for "hot chocolate effect" yielded 8 hits,
>including the one listed below which explains the effect:
The link above gives the explanation that I have always offered in
the past to my students until one day I tried something new. Now
when I hear the explanation I say, "not so fast -- let me show you
Try this for yourself. You need your coffee cup, a metal spoon, and
fresh hot water out of the tap. That's all -- no other ingredients.
Fill the cup with hot water (it comes out of the tap aerated) and tap
the lip of the cup with your spoon (continuously). You'll hear the
pitch go DOWN, stay down for a while, and then go UP (a couple of
octaves or so). The pitch depends on the speed of sound in the fluid
and that, in turn, is dependent on the overall density of the fluid.
But if the change in pitch is due only to the bubbles in the fluid
(which are rising to the surface), why does the pitch go down first
and then up? BTW, this doesn't happen with hot chocolate stirred in
-- it just goes up.